What kind of Director would YOU be? The kind that encouraged actors to be creative or the kind that insisted they stick to the script?

Demands, insistence, uncompromising and authoritarian ORDERS do not allow for spontaneous greatness. There never would have been a Jonathan Winters or Robin Williams if they always stayed within the lines and never deviated an inch from a rigid template. Which do YOU prefer? The good little folks who always follow order or the ones who surprise you with their brilliance and uniqueness and creativity and ingenuity? Why?