Active Now

Danilo_G
Discussion » Questions » Education » If Mallory and Irvine were the first to conquer Everest in 1924, why didn't they leave a marker of their presence on the peak?

If Mallory and Irvine were the first to conquer Everest in 1924, why didn't they leave a marker of their presence on the peak?

1. **They Did Not Reach the Summit**: The most straightforward explanation is that Mallory and Irvine did not make it to the summit. They may have perished during their descent or been forced to turn back due to exhaustion, weather, or equipment failure. If they never reached the top, they would not have left a marker there.

2. **The Marker Was Lost or Overlooked**: If they did reach the summit, any marker they left could have been lost or destroyed over time due to the harsh conditions on Everest. High winds, snow, and ice could have buried or swept away any evidence. Additionally, subsequent climbers may have overlooked it during their own ascents.

3. **They Did Not Carry a Marker**: Mallory and Irvine may not have carried a physical marker to leave at the summit. In 1924, the concept of leaving a marker or flag on the peak was not as established as it is today. Their primary goal was likely to reach the summit and return safely, rather than to leave proof of their achievement.

4. **The Camera Was Not Found**: Mallory was known to have carried a camera, and if they reached the summit, they might have taken a photograph as proof. However, the camera was never recovered, and its film, if it still exists, has not been developed. Without this evidence, their success remains unconfirmed.

5. **Focus on Survival**: If they did reach the summit, they may have been in such a dire state—exhausted, oxygen-deprived, or injured—that leaving a marker was not a priority. Their focus may have shifted entirely to surviving the descent.
 

____________
 
No, the camera belonging to George Mallory and Andrew "Sandy" Irvine, which could potentially prove if they reached the summit of Everest, has not been found despite the discovery of Mallory's body in 1999; the camera remains missing, and recent discoveries of partial remains of Irvine also did not include the camera. 
 
Key points about the missing camera:
  • Belonged to Mallory:
    The camera in question was a Kodak Vest Pocket camera that Mallory borrowed from another climber on the 1924 expedition, Howard Somervell. 
     
  • Potential evidence:
    If found, the developed film inside the camera could provide crucial evidence regarding whether Mallory and Irvine reached the summit of Everest. 
     
  • No camera found with remains:
    When Mallory's body was discovered, the camera was not present. 
     
  • Recent Irvine discovery:
    While a portion of Irvine's remains (a boot with his foot inside) was found recently, the camera was still not located. 

The mystery of Mallory and Irvine's final climb continues to captivate mountaineers and historians. Until conclusive evidence is found, their achievement remains one of the great unanswered questions in the history of exploration.

Posted - 7 hours ago

Responses