Discussion»Statements»Rosie's Corner» If you leave a "war" that you didn't win because a victory was never proclaimed does that mean you lost? What's the story on Afghanistan?
Very nice Sharon. You know I ADORE rhymes so thanks for that. Personally I think Humpty Dumpty is much handsomer than YO-YO boy. Not my cuppa tea. Not my type. Thank you for your reply and Happy Tuesday! :)
Afganistan now has a government which, while upholding a conservative Muslim way of life, does not support the extremist fundamentalist views of the Taliban. Yet the Taliban continue to be a sickly thorn in the side of the country with their continuing atrocities and acts of terrorism.
Recently, America, Australia and the U.N. have been maintaining skeletal forces there to help train the Afgan Govt's forces in how to deal with terrorism - attempting to help the Govt maintain as much peace and security as possible.
Yesterday, the Afgan Govt and the Taliban agreed to negotiate a truce and peace talks. Part of the deal is a request for foreign troops to leave.
Like Vietnam, I don't believe that the Western forces "won" in Afganistan. We had a partial win in that we helped to install and stabilise a govt with policies somewhat less odious to Western values and interests. For myself, because I value women's rights and education, I would prefer to see Afganistan under a modernised and liberal regime. But I am not comfortable with the idea of the West continuously imposing its values on others. So I am ambivalent about the issue.
When is it right to intervene in another's affairs to prevent injustice, cruelty and suffering? Should we not look twice before leaping? Should we not study all aspects of a culture deeply and really understand what we are doing before acting? Look at the mess we created in Iraq! We made things far worse because we understood nothing of the society and its dynamics below the surface. Would it not be better to examine ourselves and fix our own injustices, cruelties and sufferings in our home countries?
I feel nervous about the outcome of the peace talks because I'm not sure what kinds of compromises they will reach or whether they will work in the long run.
I can't see the Taliban letting go of their fanaticism any time soon - but given enough time, I think they could unwittingly destroy themselves from within.
Thank you for a very thoughtful, helpful and informative analysis in response to my question NdP. I appreciate it. Afghanistan is our longest "war" I've read. It goes on and on and on endlessly. For what purpose I did not know. I don't know the answer to your question..when to intervene and when to butt out. Usually if there is oil involved we butt in. If it is just genocide we stay out. Nothing to gain there . SIGH. I guess. It could be a ruse. It just seems unjust that American troops keep dying there. One by one by one. Year after year after year. Drip drip drip. I guess whatever is "meant to be will be". Of course no one can know what that is. Happy Tuesday! :)
This post was edited by RosieG at January 29, 2019 3:06 AM MST