Discussion » Questions » Human Behavior » Have you ever thought to determine whether you are left brain dominant or right brain dominant?

Have you ever thought to determine whether you are left brain dominant or right brain dominant?

If it matters at all.. or you may be 'middle of the road' brained.

Posted - March 2, 2019

Responses


  • 46117
    I think this theory was debunked.




    The left-brain right-brain myth will probably never die because it has become a powerful metaphor for different ways of thinking – logical, focused and analytic versus broad-minded and creative. Take the example of Britain’s Chief Rabbi Jonathan Sacks talking on BBC Radio 4 earlier this year. “What made Europe happen and made it so creative,” he explained, “is that Christianity was a right-brain religion … translated into a left-brain language [Greek]. So for many centuries you had this view that science and religion are essentially part of the same thing.”

    As well as having metaphorical appeal, the seductive idea of the right brainand its untapped creative potential also has a long history of being targeted by self-help gurus peddling pseudo-psychology. Today the same idea is also picked up by the makers of self-improvement video games and apps. The latest version of the The Faces iMake-Right Brain Creativity app for the Ipad, for example, boasts that it is “an extraordinary tool for developing right brain creative capabilities”.

    There is more than a grain of truth to the left-brain right-brain myth. While they look alike, the two hemispheres of the brain do function differently. For example, it’s become almost common knowledge that in most people the left brain is dominant for language. The right hemisphere, on the other hand, is implicated more strongly in emotional processing and representing the mental states of others. However, the distinctions aren't as clear cut as the myth makes out - for instance, the right hemisphere is involved in processing some aspects of language, such as intonation and emphasis. 

    Much of what we know about the functional differences between the hemispheres comes from the remarkable split-brain studies that began in the sixties. These investigations were conducted on patients who’d had the thick bundle of fibres connecting their hemispheres cut as a last-resort treatment for epilepsy. Researchers, including the psychologists Roger Sperry and Michael Gazzaniga, could present stimuli to just one hemisphere or the other at a time, and they discovered that the two halves of the brain acted like independent entities with contrasting processing styles.

    But it’s important to remember that in healthy people the two brain hemispheres are well-connected. The fictional doctor Gregory House called the corpus callosum that joins the hemispheres the “George Washington Bridge” of the brain, and in most of what we do, the hemispheres have evolved to operate together, sharing information across this bridge. Neuroscientists working in this field today are interested in how this coordination occurs.

    It’s also important to note that the kind of tasks that engage one hemisphere more than the other don’t always map neatly onto the kind of categories that we find useful to talk about in our everyday lives.  Let’s take the example of creativity. We may find it a useful shorthand to divide tasks up into those that are creative and those that are repetitive. But the reality of course is more complex. There are many ways to be creative.

    Some studies have indeed shown that the right hemisphere seems to be involved more when we have an Aha! flash of insight. For instance, one study found that activity was greater in the right hemisphere when participants solved a task via insight, rather than piecemeal. Anothershowed that brief exposure to a puzzle clue was more useful to the right hemisphere, than the left, as if the right hemisphere were nearer the answer.



    This post was edited by WM BARR . =ABSOLUTE TRASH at March 3, 2019 8:08 AM MST
      March 2, 2019 10:46 PM MST
    2

  • 13395
    Yes, I did do a bit of research before I asked the question and according to Psychology Today it probably is a myth but don't tell anyone. 
      March 2, 2019 10:59 PM MST
    1

  • 6988
    Having had a 'brain stroke' when I was 5, I know what it is like to have 'half a brain' that is functioning. The good half works OK, but the other half is a failure. I am poor at math, but good at story creation. Another 'half-brain' person is former lead singer of the band 'Foreigner', Lou Gramm. He developed a brain tumor that just about killed him. Over the years since, he has beaten the effects of his condition, and began touring again in his own band. I saw him in concert several years ago, and he was overweight and unrecognizable, but sounded good. 
      March 3, 2019 5:46 AM MST
    2

  • 44620
    Let's see...my right side brain has 53 remaining cells and the left has 62. So I guess the left is dominant.
      March 3, 2019 8:09 AM MST
    2