Or could the inside jokes and running gags make the site less attractive to new people?
I could meet you later to discuss it in more comfortable settings, your place, for instance . . . oh, wait. It’s stuff like this that’s exactly what you mean, right? Oops.
~
There, there, Honey.
~
Gee, not one typographical error, not a single one. Great job!
~
You sound surprised, but I don’t know why.
~