I will nominate Winston Churchill. While he was undoubtedly an excellent wordsmith and orator, and he was a reasonably skilled diplomat, I think his reputation is a bit overblown.
Churchill has become something of a deity for the TradCon right, who ignore his enormous military failures (the Gallipoli campaign in WWI was a disaster, and Churchill's insistence upon attacking Italy in WWII wasted resources best used elsewhere), as well as Churchill's unwavering defense of the British Empire and its right to dominate/subjugate the "lesser races."
It is a curious thing that Churchill has a better reputation in America than he does in Great Britain (whose people, we shouldn't forget, dumped Churchill almost as soon as WWII was over).