I find the words to the 'Pina Colada' song to be defective. When she discovers her boyfriend is the person responding to the ad, she says; "Oh, it's you'. That is silly. There is no sense of surprise or shock there. That's like saying; "oh, big deal". That kinda kills the amazing story that the song brings. They probably went home and slept in separate beds, no tender lovemaking like the listener would expect.