I saw your answer here earlier and thought of it later - - when I heard Meat Loaf singing his hit "I'll Do Anything for Love but I Won't Do That" -- I hate the song and usually don't like MeatLoaf for the same reasons - - he usually sounds to me that he's not good. :)
He got away with sounding like that because the songs mattered. He's arguably the greatest lyricist in history, Nobel Laureate in literature. But every cover of a Dylan song sounds better that the original, even Knockin' On Heaven's Door which was surprising because Axl Rose can't sing either.
Ever heard of a Dutch soprano called Amira Willighagen? If you're not enchanted by the angelic purity of this child's voice, you have a heart of solid ice and your ears are in your butt. When she won Holland's Got Talent, she was nine.