A guy (fellow atheist) related this event that happened recently -he was lying in bed late one evening when he heard sound of shattering glass in his house. He got up to find out the cause and found a glass plate had come out of a closed cupboard door and smashed on the floor in the kitchen. No explanation how. No intruder, his doors all locked up, totally sure he never left the plate on the edge of his counter. Mystery.
My own experiences -years ago i'd seen my doctor to get a form, a statement that would qualify me for disability. I took the paper home and put it in the top drawer of a desk. Later to make the appointment to see my social worker with the document I opened the desk drawer: no paper. I searched the other drawers and around the room; it had totally disappeared. I did find it some time -months later in one of the lower drawers. Mystery.
Another time early this year I got my income tax slips in the mail I put put them on top my pile of papers in a chest of drawers. When time came to take the slips and have my income tax filed I took the slips from top of the pile and had someone do the paperwork for me. Then I got a letter from Revenue Canada saying they received tax slips from year 2016 instead of 2017 so I gotta fix it. How did my 2016 slips get to the top of the pile from being buried underneath somewhere. Anyway I found my 2017 slips at the bottom of the pile of papers and got things fixed up.
No idea how that could have happened. Mystery mystery.
Okay? Let's play your silly game.
If they always existed, doesn't that make little sense even to you? You claim or your atheist buddies claim that we don't live forever. Where does our particles go? What about the YOU part of the equation? Do you think that just happened? How? How did you get born? Were you the exchange of matter and energy? Okay. Where did that energy and matter come from? If everything always was and always will be? No beginning?
Well, if there is no beginning HOW THE HELL DO YOU KNOW THIS.
PROVE THAT THERE WAS NO BEGINING. Prove it. And don't hand me some bs about Scientific Law.
That was something that came out of the mind of Scientists. How do they know. Were they there?
Hawking himself couldn't figure it out. I'm sure there was this big reason. Because it does not work that way.
There are scientists who only can go from one fact to another. Those facts change as much as their data. It is not written in stone. It CHANGES the more scientists learn. And the more they learn, the closer they GET TO THE FACT THAT WHEN YOU BREAK DOWN THE SMALLEST PARTICLE, THERE IS NOTHING. SO THOSE PARTICLES CAME FROM no thing. no thing.
Scientific LAW. Read.
Those particles came from no thing. Therefore, some THING had to create the reason for their existence.
They didn't just decide all by themselves to appear. How? How did they just appear.