I always thought that was mean... the bit about the puppy dogs' tails... I mean poor puppies! Unless this was when they used to doc dogs' tails and so someone went around collectin... moreI always thought that was mean... the bit about the puppy dogs' tails... I mean poor puppies! Unless this was when they used to doc dogs' tails and so someone went around collecting all the puppy dog tails? And if the idea is that the ingredients are horrid - surely that's not so with puppy dog tails? Me. I am made of sugar and spice and all things nice :P